the barrel


the rev dr john h pavelko

The Barrel - Home Page

from our pastor - blog

illustrations

resources

sermon study guide

year c - 6th sunday in ordinary time

1 corinthians 15:12-20

Filtering Through the Theological Spam

MESSAGES FILTERS

The Internet was supposed to be a vast array of free-floating ideas and information enhancing our lives by improving communication and increasing our productivity. Unfortunately, it has become a back alley of get rich schemes, pornography and unbridled advertisements. The information highway is jammed with unwanted e-mail, not-so affectionately known as spam. Messages that promise us health, wealth and prosperity invade our mailboxes throughout the day. Almost weekly, I receive a request from Nigeria promising more than a million dollars if I help them transfer $10 million dollars. All that I must do is supply them with my bank account. The most galling are those unwanted solicitations for anti-spam software.

Spam is not only irritating, a time waster and offensive, but it also holds the potential for unwanted viruses. Some software companies have expended large amounts of money and time to designing software that will filter out these unwanted messages. There are two requirements for anti-spam software. First, it must detect spam e-mail. Secondly, it must not filter out legitimate e-mail. That may sound rather obvious but in the world of computers, it is not a simple assignment.

I tried developing my own system. I set my messages filters to look words usually found commonly found in spam mail. That tactic brought temporary relieve until the spammers realized what people were doing. This last week I resorted to more desperate measures. I deleted the spam filters and directed all my e-mail to the Trash folder except for the e-mails from people in my personal address book. This has reduced the flow of junk e-mails to my Inbox but I now must check my Trash folder before I empty it to make sure that an e-mail was not accidentally diverted.

Filtering unwanted messages is a problem in cyberspace and in the church. Anyone who can type on a keyboard, use a pen or speak can litter the religious landscape with distorted ideas and beliefs. Over the years, books have been published that qualify under the heading 'theological spam.' The Passover Plot, suggested that the disciples might have given Jesus a hallucinogenic drug just before the crucifixion swooning him into a death-like trance. Assuming that he was dead, the Romans allowed him to be entombed. A few days later the disciples returned to the grave, resuscitated him with a narcotic and proclaimed resurrection. 

The brother of Jesus, James, was given the lead role in another theory presented by Professor A. N. Wilson. According to this idea, James showed up on the road to Emmaus and was mistakenly identified as Jesus. And more recently, The DaVinci Code has offered its own set of suggestions that reinterpret the historical events.

The latest theories have several common themes. Creativity replaces academic credibility. The historical authenticity of orthodox beliefs succumbs to speculative imagination. For the uninformed layperson that lacks a sophisticated filter, the arguments may appear quite plausible. The untrained theologian may become confused and assimilate these 'new' ideas even though they contradict the basic tenets of the faith. To prevent the adoption of heretical teaching we must learn to develop filters that sort through the theological spam. In his letter to the Corinthians, the apostle Paul demonstrates how to analysis ideas to determine their validity. 

FILTERING THROUGH THE ILLOGICAL

Pluralism marked the theological climate of the ancient world just as it does today. Several different streams of philosophy influenced the thought of Greek society. Most viewed the body and soul as separate components. Some believed that the soul perished at with the cessation of life. The soul was consumed in the pile of fire when the body was burnt. Another school of thought advocated for the eternal existence of the soul but both denied the resurrection of the dead although they were willing to accept that the resurrection of Jesus. 

Paul directs his rebuttal at the logic of this limited view by using conditional clauses. He states that if their position is true then we must draw certain conclusions. If the dead are not raised than how can you be sure that Christ is not raised? For Paul, the two events have an inseparable link. One cannot take place without the other. If God is not able to resurrect one man, than he is not able to resurrect anyone. Or to reverse the argument, if God is not able to resurrect us, why would he resurrect Jesus. 

Paul does not provide scientific or historical evidence for the resurrection to prove his argument. The Corinthians were already convinced of the historical event. They would have joined Paul in defending its reality against attack by the skeptics. But they failed to see how the philosophy of the culture had influenced their thinking. They had taken one statement of truth and combined it with a falsehood. Paul states that those two ideas simply cannot coexist. They are logical opposites. Before we accept a new idea, we should consider the logic of its premise to what we already know to be true.

FILTERING THROUGH THE FUTILE

After exposing the illogic of the variant argument, Paul then uses another filters through the consequences of its teaching. What if we do not have a risen Christ? And what if we do not have a resurrection, what consequence does it have in my day-to-day living? Paul tells them that a resurrection-less theology has enormous consequences because without a resurrection we are still dead in our sin.

Last fall Carol and I decided to brighten up our yard by planting daffodils, tulips, hyacinths and crocus along the borders of several of our flowerbeds. Bulbs are amazing. Before they are planted, they appear lifeless and dead. They will lie dormant for years, even centuries. Through the cold winter months they will remain inactive until the warmth of spring resurrection them to life. Then they absorb water and nutrients from the soil and grow, push their stems through the soil and spread their beautiful array of blossoms. The resurrection of Christ is our spring. Without his triumphant exit from the tomb, we would remain lifeless and dormant entombed by the enslaving grip of sin. His resurrection breaths life into us just as the change in weather brings bulbs to life. That historical event becomes the most effective filter for detecting the orthodoxy of religious teaching. 

Without the resurrection, the work of God in Jesus would have ended "...in the cul-de-sac of a Palestinian grave.... Death [would have remained] stronger than God.... [and] God's acts [would have] proven futile...."1 Those that deny that historical event remove the last chapter of God's salvation history. Stripped of resurrection power, the believer is forced to live out ethical teachings of Christ through human effort. The Sermon on the Mount becomes a legalist code of conduct impossible to emulate even for a brief moment. 

The filter of futility removes many of the speculative theories that may appear attractive but prove powerless and ineffective.

FILTERING THOUGHT TO HOPE

Having dissected the illogical and exposed the futility of the teaching offered by those who deny a resurrection Paul applies the filter of hope
 

But Christ has indeed been raised from the dead the first fruit of those who have fallen asleep... (I Corinthians 15:20)


Paul employs the term first fruits to remind the Corinthians that the resurrection of Jesus was not a solo event. "Christ is never without his people"2 He represents the whole harvest that is to come but until that great day they must wait.

WAITING TILL MORNING

The pastor took his seat as the airplane prepared for take off. Sitting beside the pastor was a well known theologian. Thrilled by the opportunity to talk with such a distinguished scholar, the pastor initiated a conversation. After a few minutes the scholar talked about his family. He told the pastor that one day his young son came home from school with a fever. They gave him some aspirin and sent him to bed thinking it was just one of those childhood things. Before the night was over, they were in the emergency room. The boy had a very virulent form of meningitis. The doctors had to tell the professor that his son was going to die. Shocked by the news, the seminary professor assumed a seat beside his son to wait. 

By mid-afternoon, the little boy's strength was depleted. With his vision becoming cloudy, he said, "Daddy, it's getting dark isn't it?" The professor replied, "yes, son it is getting dark, very dark." A few minutes passed and the boy said, "Daddy,

loving his son as he did, sat by the bed side to watch this death I guess its time for me to go to sleep isn't it?"

He said, "Yes, son, it's time for you to go to sleep."

The professor said that his fixed his pillow and put his head on his head just as he had done every other night and said, "Good night Daddy. I will see you in the morning." He then closed his eyes and took his final breath.

The professor looked out the window of the airplane for a long time as the pastor sat in silence grieving for his new friend. Eventually, the professor turned, looked at the pastor and with tears streaming down his cheeks said, "Pastor, I can hardly wait till the morning."3

We can only wait till morning if we have a hope that is not shaped by creative imagination or vain speculation. Our hope rest in the assurance that just as God raised Jesus of Nazareth from stone grave, he will one day resurrect us to eternal life.



1 George Eldon Ladd, I Believe in the Resurrection of Jesus, (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1975), 144.
2 F. W. Grosheide, The First Epistle to the Corinthians, NICNT, (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1953), 362.
3 The story was first told by Dr. Criswell, Pastor of the First Baptist Church, Dallas TX cited by Brett Blair, www.eSer

© 2000-11 All material including but not limited to information, images, graphics, and email addresses is published strictly for the spiritual edification of the viewers and may not be used without the express permission of the Crossroads Presbyterian Church.

Send a note to the Pastor


Email: pastorjohn @ crossroadspc.org
(Hint: Spaces have been added to confuse unscrupulous spamers. To email Pastor John, remove the spaces.)


Crossroads Presbyterian Church
1445 Welch Rd
Walled Lake MI 48390


Office - (248) 624-3821


This page is viewed best with
Meet the world's best web browser!